jake's mom


Critics != Everyone Else.

Ever noticed that critics tend to be out of step with everyone else? The NYT did.

At Rottentomatoes.com, a Web site that quantifies movie reviews on a 100-point scale, the aggregate score for “Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest” stands at a sodden 54. Metacritic.com, a similar site, crunches the critical prose of the nation’s reviewers and comes up with a numerical grade of 52 out of 100. Even in an era of rampant grade inflation, that’s a solid F.

Meanwhile, over at boxofficemojo.com, where the daily grosses are tabulated, the second installment in the “Pirates” series, which opened on July 7, plunders onward, trailing broken records in its wake. Its $136 million first-weekend take was the highest three-day tally in history, building on a best-ever $55 million on that Friday, and it is cruising into blockbuster territory at a furious clip. As of this writing, a mere 10 days into its run, the movie has brought in $258.2 million, a hit by any measure.

Why does this happen? It's pretty obvious. Critics are people who tend to be really passionate about movies. They also tend to have seen many, many movies and will rapidly grow tired of run-of-the-mill plots, shoddy acting, and explosions. Instead, they applaud new, strange, and inventive filmmaking with interesting plots and richly-developed characters. I'd also speculate that many film critics are more highly educated than the average American, and therefore appreciate a higher level of humor than that present in, say, White Chicks.

Typical Americans, on the other hand, see only a few movies a year and probably choose to watch them for a "good time" or for an escape from real life. Joe Six-Pack wants to see cute "chic-flicks" (only with the wife, of course), explosive "save the world" movies, and "humorous" buddy comedies.

The same thing goes for music, fine art, and writing. Tell me how many professional critics love this song, this painting, or this book. They won't win any awards, but they sure sell well.

Surprise, surprise. End of debate.
posted by brian at 3:24 PM | Permalink

4 Comment(s) - Click to View/Hide



[ contributors ]
-contact us-

[ links ]
curious character
common sense dancing
relative path
american progress
daily kos
democracy for america
talking points memo
andrew tobias
angels twenty
largehearted boy
soma fm
the big ticket

Add to MyYahoo This page is powered by Blogger.